BEST OF BRITISH
I was giving some thought to this six-plus-five foreigner restriction proposal put forward by UEFA a few weeks back.
Thank God's it's fallen by the wayside. Just how would Liverpool fare if that scenario was introduced?
How would we have lined up? And what impact would it have on the English game?
If the ruling was brought in tomorrow with only five foreigners allowed, Liverpool would struggle to put out a competitive team.
Let's presume UK players could count within the six (ie Wales, Scotland and Ireland allowed), we'd probably line up something like this:
Reina, Finnan, Carragher, Skrtel, Aurelio, Pennant, Gerrard, Guthrie, Kuyt, Torres, Crouch.
Nothing to speak of on the bench is there? Hobbs and the reserve keeper Martin. I've never seen him play. Hope he's not another Charlie The Tang.
It's a sad state of affairs in reality as I'm sure The Kop would love nothing more than to roar on a Woolton winger, Fazakerley centre forward or show their approval towards a Norris Green centre half.
The nurturing of young British talent has been woefully neglected over the last 15 years in England.
It must grate for some of the Liverpool kids who dream every night about playing at Anfield and signing professional terms, only to see some foreign unheard of walking into Melwood.
Mediocre overseas recruits too - I can't see how Ferri, Cheyrou, Diao, Josemi, Nunez, Meijer, Itandje, Sissoko, Gonzalez, Kvarme and countless others had something over and above some of our local Scouse youngsters, given time.
We would have saved millions in transfer fees and wages into the bargain.
How about the example of Pongolle and Le Tallec. Two French kids coveted by a welter of Europe's top clubs.
Liverpool's persistance prevailed, Alex Ferguson even made a point of congratulating Houllier on his double Gallic coup.
What was all the fuss about? Le Tallec has delievred pretty much nothing - is he a striker or a midfielder? Nobody can tell.
Pongolle is a half decent player who'll do well at a middling side. I've got a soft spot for his energy and the way he dragged us out the mire in that epic FA Cup tie at Luton a couple of years ago.
But he's not the world beater we were led to believe who would terrorise the Premiership in a few years time.
Again, hyped up foreign players at the expense of Liverpool homegrown talent who'd no doubt turn out for the club for £100 a week if it came down to it.
Let's hope Nemeth, currently looking very impressive banging goals in for the reserves is a different kettle of fish.
A look at Liverpool's reserves is interesting. The usual line up consists of Dean Bouzanis, Péter Gulácsi, Mikel San José, Emiliano Insua, Daniel Ayala, Miki Roque, Godwin Antwi and Sebastián Leto.
The reserve side used to be the natural breeding ground from where local talent was sprung. There's barely a Scouse accent there.
There's some talent, but I can't imagine many of those progressing as first team regulars.
Against that argument, you could probably say that Liverpool's reserve side WAS predominantly English around five years ago.
That famous Carling Cup win at Spurs was achieved with the likes of Raven, Partridge and the others. They had their chance to line up alongisde Gerrard and Co, but it seemed they couldn't quite make the grade.
But then our youth policy, from the scouting through to the training and development, doesn't seem to have been the same since the halcyon days of Fowler, Owen Carragher and Gerrard.
This state of affairs impacts massively on the British game and the performance of the national side.
Not that every or many Liverpool fans cares. The Reds faithful are well known for their indifference to the success of England at major championships.
Of course, there's a reason why managers have turned to unheard of foreigners to flood our game.
Money.
Or the inflated value placed on English players by greedy managers. Martin O'Neill anyone?
Gary Cahill for £4m? Crouch worth £15m? Milner being touted around at £10m. They are worth around half that in my book.
If you're lucky and you've got an astute manager in the transfer market like Arsene Wenger and you can spot Euro gems for peanuts (Fabregas, Flamini, Hleb, Clichy etc) then you probably don't give two hoots if they're screaming Moroccan and Malian on the pitch.
But as much as we turn people like Sami, Riise, Kuyt and Hysen into honorary Scousers, it would be refreshing to hear a screaming defender (other than Carra) imploring his colleagues: "Let's have a red 'ead on this eh?!'
Some foreign stars are great and their influence can enrich our game. Zola and Vialli for Chelsea suddenly made the Premiership sexy.
A Danish Molby was the best passer we'd seen at Anfield for years, perhaps Anfield's greatest passer.
And the technique of Alonso and Garcia and the discipline of Hyppia and Henchoz taught our kids a lot.
But it's gone too far.
Can anyone honestly say what we've learnt from the lovable El Hadji Diouf other than how to grock in someone's eye?
![]()
Older/Newer
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: BEST OF BRITISH.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.luketraynor.merseyblogs.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/11458


It's been like this for years. The FA, the Premier League need to get a hold of things, and start taking action.
I think UEFA's rule would have ben a good one, would have sorted out the foreign imbalance once and for all.
It's soft really, we get rid of good platers like Murphy and Thompson and replace them with dross like Lucas, and Alonso.
For all Xabi's supposed class on the ball, I'd take Murphy any day. More goals, more tenacity, gets involved loads more.
But if you're a manager what you going to do when some Scandanavian centre half is a quarter of the price of some Championship centre half.
Buy overseas of course.
One of Blatter's better idea this one. Shame it didn't go through.
You only have to lookmat the price of English players now to see why this would not work - no-one could afford to buy anyone.
It is already ridiculous now with Barry costing £18m and Bentley the same. They'r good players, but the fact they're English means their fee goes through the roof.
Neil,
I blame idiot players sho go to big players thinking they'll get a game even when they are fifth in line. Serves Sidwell right what has happened to him.
Glen Johnson too, could have held down a regular palce anywhere else