MILNER, VILLA, ABIDAL ET AL
THE Newcastle winger James Milner is the latest potential signing to be linked to Liverpool.
If you've believe what you read in The Telegraph(!!), the deal is nearing completion.
Is this the kind of positive news we wanted to hear?
From my sightings of Milner on Sky and Match of the Day, he's always seemed like a decent player to me.
Positive, fairly direct, capable of scoring goals.
However, the ECHO editor, a Magpies fan, informs me that Milner is not what the Reds need.
Apparently, he's not of the quality that Liverpool demand. Limited pace and trickery. Good attitude and a trier, but short on real class and not a week-in week-out match winner.
Fair enough.
I can't help thinking, however, that he'd be an improvement on Pennant who seems more interested in appearing alongside his belle in Hollyoaks.
The Telegraph reckon £7m AND Danny Guthrie will see the Toon part with Milner.
Even if there's a truth in this story, that's a ridiculous valuation even in today's crazy world of inflated transfer values.
From what I'vs seen of Guthrie, the lad's got a future as a centre-mid. Bolton love him where he's been on loan and he'd probably fetch £3m, so Newcastle reckon Milner is worth £10m if my maths are correct?
Settle down Kevin.

Bentley is the bloke we need. Genuine class, two good feet, very good crosser. Scores lots of goals. To quote many an internet forum warrior, 'he would do a job for us - FACT' (you've got to use the word 'FACT'. That's what makes opinions gospel, apparently)
But the Blackburn man would no doubt cost £15+ and the growing and worrying suspicion is that the credit crunch, coupled with Huck's and Rafa's current mistrust of each other means the piggy bank is gloomily low.
The Villa/Torres partnership coming to Anfield is the stuff dreams are made of. They've been slick at the Euros.
Many would sacrifice all other buys just to get him and I can sympathise with that sentiment, they would rip defences apart every weekend.
An astute businessman would raise £50m from the combined sales of Alonso, Riise, Kewell, Pennant, Crouch, Carson and Voronin to blow it all on the Valencia front man.
But that would mean an astute businessman being in place at Anfield.
But it's doubtful if Villa will make it to Anfield, even if he is best mates with Pepe Reina and he likes hugging Torres.
If nothing else, Stevie would become jealous.
Let's dispense with the Barry idea. It was a decent suggestion while figures of £8m were talked about, but £15m is ridiculous.
We've got Gerrard, Masherano, Lucas (big question marks over him), a promising young Plessis and Guthrie if we want him back.
And Yossi definitely prefers playing in the centre where he is much more effective.
I mentioned Abidal in the title as we were strongly linked with him a while ago and he came to the fore in all the wrong ways last night.
I'm glad those rumours died a death, I never did like him.
Obviously he was red carded against the Italians last night, but that sums him up doesn't it? All-round oafishness and clumsiness.
He was exactly the same when Barca played Man Utd in the Champions League semi. No touch, no finesse, a bit of a clogger...worth £10m, we were told us. Next please.
Let's get the shipping in and shipping out moving. Give Riise to Roma for £4m. And let Harry Redknapp have Crouchy for £10m rather than clinging on for another £5m were not going to get.
It's all about doing these deals so we are in a position to move for the best players when they come available.
Finnan too. It became apparent at the end of last season that those legs that have served us well in recent years are on the wane and he's not the Mr Dependable he used to be. Those great crosses have dried up too.
With our two new full backs of Degen and Dossena, and Arbeloa and Aurelio not going anywhere, keeping him would man a pointless £50,000-ish grand being shelled out every week.
A Premiership side would still be interested in him and he'd fetch around £4m.

It's simple when you write it down, but all this wheeling and dealing requires energy behind the scenes at Anfield.
And the indicators are that the determination to make things happen isn't there, almost certainly brought on by the damaging rift between manager, chief executive and owner which has resulted in an immovable deadlock in the Anfield corridors.
All the charm offensives and positive PR in the world can't hide that.
At a time when Rafa, Parry and Hicks should be on the phone to each other a few times every day, they've probably not even received a text from each other in months.
I was surprised to see the Texan come out and tell Chelsea Torres was staying at Anfield the other day. All very commendable Tom, but let's hear instead what we ARE doing.
For the sake of Reds everywhere - open the lines of communication and represent the millions of Liverpool fans who realise that these two months could be the most important of the season.
Older/Newer
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: MILNER, VILLA, ABIDAL ET AL.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.luketraynor.merseyblogs.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/10604



Well said. All that bluster in that press conference how we were gojng to conquer the world. We get to the first proper spending window as we sit twiddling our thumbs.
Tom, George, Rick, Rafa. Ths situation is not going to allow us to compete at the top table.
Please sort it out.
The crazy prices being talked about in respect of Milner, Bentley and Barry are exactly the reason why English players are so far down the list when it comes to a list of potential purchases. Couldn't agree more with what you say about those targets being completely unrealistic at current prices - lets not be taken for a ride. As for the silence coming out of Anfield - I'm not too concerned. I've never been a big fan of talking up a signing before you make your move, it only stifles the deal and makes the price more restrictive - Barry being the prime example. If there's still no talk of transfers a few weeks after the window opens thats the time to start worrying, not now. As for Villa, woudl it really be a dream partnership with no one to unlock defences and slot the strikers in? I'd rather buy a world class winger than Villa if we had to make the choice. Torres will score more again next season when given the service and I woudldn't be surprised to see our Dutch duo weigh in with a good compliment as well.
Luke,
Liverpool have scouted Bentley three times last season and are not impressed. He won;t be joining this summer.
The Milner link is ahead of the forthcoming decision over limitations on foreign players in EPL sides.
I fear Milner isn't good enough either.
I'd suggest something different which you may mock. Sell Gerrard to raise the cash for Villa.
Bear with me....Gerrard has been a top player, captain and servant to LFC. But like Lampard at Chelsea, I believe we have had his best days. Let him go off to Europe and let us create the most fearosome strike force in Europe.
Imagine it....
i think we should bring a world class winger like david silva or quaresema instead of buying villa bcoz as we saw last season the partnership of gerrard and torres was faboulous so we need wingers badly and a right and a left midfielders...
Barry is a must-but for our midfield. Fact.
I would say he is worth up to £18m.
Any team looking for a forward (and we are as Crouch will be gone this summer), and doesn't look at Villa as an option is backward thinking.
I fear the ramifications of not signing quality this summer.
And the club should not be held to ransom over Barry or Milner (who I fear would be a less trickier version of Pennant).
If there is no Barry transfer, 'd rather we went for Diarra in a swop deal with Pompy and Crouch.
We value our players too highly. If we get £12m for Alonso, I'd say take the money.
You could argue only one striker is Liverpool quality. Crouch decent but not quality enough, Dirk a great lad, but more effective as a hard working inside right, and Voronin..surely we can't give this bloke another season?
As a Villa fan, I really want to keep hold of Barry, but fear his heart is set on going to Anfield.
He's not worth over £15m though, and for that you can have him.
I respect Martin O'Neill for not rolling over in the face of some blatant tapping up from Rafa and Gerrard almost publically demanding where Gareth goes.
Shameful that.
Bentley at Anfield.....ugh....what a horrible idea....first he'll be hopelessly over priced !!!!.....second...can you picture him on the bench after one of Rafas' rotation (he'd never keep his mouth shut!!!) I can see the headlines now "Bentley won't rotate...Bentley warns Rafa not to rotate him..."....be honest...you know it's true...and with the ownership saga sure to continue LFC needs a "trouble maker" in the dressing room like they need a 'hole in the head'....RANT over.
skyner, you said: "As for Villa, woudl it really be a dream partnership with no one to unlock defences and slot the strikers in?"
what do you mean? you suggesting, they are both out and out front men and neither drops deep to lay on the other? I think they dovetail and chop and change beautifully. Euro 2008 shining example.
As for wingers, there's hardly any good ones. Gonzalez, Garcia, Kewell, Pennant, Nunez, Babel, Cheyrou and many more all tried and failed.
Dude - good name bad idea!
Torres and Gerrard dovetailed beautifuly for most of last season - it still wasn't enough in the end. In an ideal world we'd buy Villa and a great winger but in reality we'll only be able to afford one so it has to be the winger and leave Torres and Gerrard to further their partnership. You have to look at the bigger picture and mae the best team out of whatever resources are available - not just play fantasy fotball and games of "We want ..."
Skyner - disagree. Striker's win you games and titles, not wingers. Largely speaking, Ronaldo an exception.
Kuyt seems to be pencilling in for right hand side, so all we need as a half decent left winger, maybe babel to get to learn the position a bit more. Trust me, a top top quality striker is preferable to a top top quality winger.